docs(box): document the box.enabled toggle and gate behavior matrix

- docker-compose: move ``langbot_box`` under compose profiles
  (``box`` and ``all``) so ``docker compose up`` no longer requires
  the sandbox container. Inline comment explains how to pair the
  profile choice with ``box.enabled`` so the langbot service does not
  thrash trying to reach a runtime that was never started
- docs/review/box-architecture.md:
  - Annotate ``box.enabled`` in the config.yaml example, listing the
    exact side effects (no remote/stdio connect; tools/skills/MCP
    stdio off; reads still work)
  - Replace the bare compose snippet with the actual profile-driven
    invocation and the BOX__ENABLED pairing
  - New "关闭/连接失败时的行为矩阵" section: a single table mapping
    every consumer (native tools, activate/register_skill, stdio MCP,
    skill list/CRUD, pipeline AI config, extensions page, dashboard)
    to its disabled-state behavior, plus the legacy ``ap.box_service``
    distinguisher note

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
Junyan Qin
2026-05-20 17:20:54 +08:00
parent 446099ecda
commit f7ee2c0961
2 changed files with 44 additions and 1 deletions

View File

@@ -18,9 +18,16 @@ services:
networks:
- langbot_network
# The Box sandbox runtime is optional. It is only started when you run
# ``docker compose --profile box up`` (or ``docker compose --profile all
# up``). With Box off, LangBot keeps the dashboard / skills list visible
# (read-only) but disables sandbox tools, skill add/edit and stdio MCP —
# set ``box.enabled: false`` in ``data/config.yaml`` (or
# ``BOX__ENABLED=false`` in the langbot service env below) to match.
langbot_box:
image: rockchin/langbot:latest
container_name: langbot_box
profiles: ["box", "all"]
volumes:
# Keep the source and target path identical because langbot_box uses the
# host Docker socket to create sandbox containers. Override

View File

@@ -504,6 +504,13 @@ Box 额外做了 RPC SHUTDOWN 通知 Runtime 主动清理容器,比 Plugin 的
```yaml
box:
enabled: true # 整个 Box 子系统的总开关。设为 false 时:
# - 不连接远程 Box runtime不 fork 本地 stdio 子进程
# - sandbox 工具 (exec/read/write/edit/glob/grep) 不暴露给 LLM
# - skill 添加/编辑 / GitHub 安装 / 文件写入全部拒绝
# - stdio 模式的 MCP server 启动时报错http/sse 模式不受影响)
# - skill 列表/读取保持只读可用
# BOX__ENABLED 环境变量可覆盖(统一约定)
backend: 'local' # 'local' (探测) / 'docker' / 'nsjail' / 'e2b'
# BOX_BACKEND 环境变量优先级更高
runtime:
@@ -529,12 +536,41 @@ box:
### docker-compose.yaml
`langbot_box` 服务受 compose profile 控制,默认 `docker compose up` **不会**启动它。需要 sandbox 时:
```bash
docker compose --profile box up # 启动 langbot + langbot_box + plugin runtime
docker compose --profile all up # 同上
docker compose up # 只起 langbot + plugin runtime (box 关闭)
```
若不起 `langbot_box`,需要同步在 `data/config.yaml` 中设 `box.enabled: false`(或 langbot 容器 env 加 `BOX__ENABLED=false`),否则 LangBot 会一直尝试连接不存在的 Box runtime 并报错。
```yaml
# langbot_box 的关键 volume
volumes:
- ./data/box:/workspaces # 工作区挂载
- ${LANGBOT_BOX_ROOT}:${LANGBOT_BOX_ROOT} # 工作区挂载(源/目标同路径)
- /var/run/docker.sock:/var/run/docker.sock # Docker backend 复用宿主 docker
```
### 关闭/连接失败时的行为矩阵
`box.enabled = false` 与"启用但连接失败"在用户可观察行为上**完全一致**——都通过 `BoxService.available = False` 表达,只是 `get_status` 多返回 `enabled` 字段供前端区分文案。
| 消费方 | Box 可用 | Box 不可用(disabled 或 failed) |
|---|---|---|
| native exec/read/write/edit/glob/grep 工具 | 暴露给 LLM | **不暴露** |
| `activate` / `register_skill` 工具 | 暴露给 LLM | **不暴露** |
| stdio MCP server | 在 Box 内启动 | **`_init_stdio_python_server` 抛 RuntimeError** 拒绝;不退化到宿主 stdio |
| http/sse MCP server | 正常 | 正常(不依赖 Box) |
| Skill 列表/读取 (`list_skills`/`get_skill`/`read_skill_file`) | 走 Box runtime | 走 LangBot 本地 `data/skills/` 只读 fallback |
| Skill 创建/编辑/安装/写文件 | 走 Box runtime | **HTTP 400** + 明确错误信息(`_require_box_for_write`) |
| Pipeline AI 配置中 `box-session-id-template` | 正常生效 | **前端 banner** 提示字段无效 |
| Pipeline 扩展页 `enable_all_skills` / 绑定 skill | 可编辑 | **前端禁用** + banner |
| 仪表盘 Box 状态卡片 | 绿点 / "已连接" | 灰点 / "已禁用"(disabled) 或 红点 / "已断开"(failed) |
> 后端拒写的边界条件:如果 `ap.box_service` **完全没装**(老式 dev mode,没经过 BuildAppStage),`_require_box_for_write` 视作 no-op,保留 `data/skills/` 本地路径——以兼容历史测试与最小化设置。生产环境总会装 `ap.box_service`,因此该 fallback 不会被触发。
### Pipeline 配置 (templates/metadata/pipeline/ai.yaml)
`local-agent.config.box-session-id-template` 控制 session 作用域,预设: